5 Reasons I’m Not Doing NaNoWriMo

November 1 marked the beginning of National Novel Writing Month 2009, an annual tradition that officially started ten years ago. For a whole month, participants deprive themselves of sleep, establish rigid and demanding word count goals, solicit peer pressure through social media. The idea is that, if you write a certain number of words a day—say, two thousand—you will have the 175-page draft of a novel ready by December 1. Then you can congratulate yourself on a difficult task accomplished or begin the slow work of revision. The NaNoWriMo website encourages you to “aim low” and just write the damn thing. Last year, of the more than 119,000 people who began the task, only 21,683 people completed their novels (defined by NaNoWriMo as “lengthy works of fiction”). It’s hard to write a novel, even a bad one.

Recently there was an article in the New York Times about the controversy surrounding marathons. Too many plodders, the hardcore runners complained: how can you call yourself a marathoner if you walked half the race? I’ve never tried to run a marathon, or even much more than a mile or two, but I can understand the positions taken by both the chubby plodders and the ropy-limbed sprinters. Serious marathoners train for months, much the way (most) serious novelists spend months or years planning, researching, and drafting. People who just want the T-shirt are out there putting one foot in front of the other, trying to finish before they open the roads to traffic. NaNoWriMo participants are to some extent like these plodders: they just want to finish, hoofing their 50,000 words across the finish line.

Though I’ve never participated in NaNoWriMo, I have written a novel and am trying to write a better one. I won’t be done in a month, and here’s why:

1. First of all, two thousand words is a lot to write in one day, especially if you’re doing this writing before or after a regular job. I don’t have one of these right now, but I think frequently about getting one, and even that takes up time. I usually write between 500 and 1,500 words a day, aiming for 1,000. I read an interview with Marilynne Robinson in which she said she didn’t believe in writing at all if she’s not inspired. Have you read the beginning of Housekeeping? That wasn’t written with “Dr. Wicked’s Write or Die” word counter on the screen.

2. Bad prose doesn’t inspire you to keep writing. My favorite part of the writing day is when I read what I wrote back to myself. This is no fun when the writing doesn’t sound nice.

3. It takes a lot of time to undo bad prose. Or ill-considered plot choices. When I think too hard about word count and page completion, I’m not at my best.

4. A lot of writing a novel is not “word-countable” anyway. It’s thinking about the characters when you wake up, while you’re at the post office, the DMV, the boring lecture, the art museum. It’s giving yourself the time to be influenced, to have your mind changed, to consider possibilities for character development, plot, language.

5. For the same reason I wouldn’t want to read a really great novel in a day, or an hour: I’d be sad when it was over too quickly. Writing a novel–beginning a novel–is a deeply enjoyable, frustrating, rewarding experience. It deserves more than 30 days.

Despite my reasons for avoiding NaNoWriMo, who know what makes something work for the individual? A family friend ran the New York City Marathon in the early 1980s. He didn’t train, smoked while he ran, and was a recovering heroin addict. The story goes that he finished in under four hours. He’s a marathoner if I’ve ever met one.



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “5 Reasons I’m Not Doing NaNoWriMo

  1. Joy

    I actually pretty much agree with all your points, but I’m also doing NaNo for the second time. Here’s why:

    * Letters in my in-box cheering me on really do help me.

    * There’s something delightful about pushing past the point where I want to stop. It’s like going running. When my lungs are holding out fine and my legs want to quit I remind myself that it’s all in my mind, and I have a lot more kick than I think I do. Sure enough, I can always run farther and get stronger.

    * I learn by making mistakes. Writing my novel a few years ago taught me so, so much. And I know that novel, as it stands now, will never see the light of day. But it was my training novel. And it led to two more years of diligent, wiser study.

    * Doing NaNo helped me truly consider myself a writer. Maybe running the New York Marathon helped the plodders consider themselves runners. And yes, it’s frustrating when the streets get choked up by people who think they can run when they don’t put in all the work for it, but — maybe those plodders will be faster next year.

    Anyway, I actually do agree with you generally (though I don’t read my own prose back to myself unless I’ve finished a first draft — writer quirk!). But NaNo’s a mixed bag, just as writing in a more meticulous fashion has some ups and downs. Hell, half of what I’ve written will get hacked out come December. But I’m also getting immense pleasure out of the feeling of high-flying speed. It’s heady. And I’ll return to my other new, partially drafted novel soon enough.

    I guess what I’m trying to say is that NaNo is a good catalyst, if that’s what you need. But if you’re content with your writing life right now, then why change?

    • Belle Boggs

      That’s great that you’re writing another novel, Joy–congratulations! I don’t really care about choked-up streets or people calling themselves novelists or marathoners (I’m not a novelist yet or much of a runner at all), I just wrote this post after considering trying NaNoWriMo for myself this year. I am very task-oriented, though, and can get too preoccupied with word count and progress (in a way that doesn’t help my writing), so I don’t think it would work for me. Richard says he’d like to try it, though!

      • Joy

        I definitely understand your logic and your considerations. And I must say it’s different doing the novel this time because — I don’t want to write another crappy book! 🙂 One was enough of a lesson for me. And truth be told, that book actually took me about five months to write — I didn’t finish it until March. So I got the delight of a whole week spent crafting the ending (which was probably the most successful part of that whole book) and also got the fun of discovering I could be prolific if I felt like it.

        I do think NaNo is best considered as an “all in good fun” sort of thing. I have another novel cooling on the back burner for a while, and that one I’m doing in the sweet, long-fashioned way.

        Maybe I’m just a fan of variety. (And of word counts! Word counts make me feel productive, even if 1000 of my 1,667 daily word minimum are pure crap.)

        The pep talks on the NaNoWriMo.org page are probably fun for anyone who’s looking for a little writerly company/comiseration. It can get lonely, this writing profession.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s